Nutrition Domus

Empowering You for a Longer Healthspan

Natural vs added sugar comparison showing whole fruits beside a glass of sugar

Natural vs Added Sugar: Is the Sugar in Fruits Bad for You?

Posted by

·

Natural vs added sugar: the two are not the same for your long-term health, and there’s a growing but largely unnecessary fear around the sugar in fruits. To shine a light on it, I compare 16 commonly eaten fruits against a can of Coke.

Key Takeaways

  • A serving of fruit can contain more sugar than half a can of soft drink. The apparently high numbers are why a lot of people are concerned with eating more fruit, although the natural sugars in fruits are largely not a health concern.
  • Fruit sugar and soft drink sugar are essentially identical. But the difference shows up primarily in how that sugar is packaged, and what else it comes with.
  • A few fruits are consistently linked with lower diabetes risk. And two large studies on opposite sides of the world came up with a strikingly similar list.
  • You don’t need to eat much fruit to reap their benefits, and fruit juice is not the same as whole fruit. Read on to find out more.
Nutrition Domus video thumbnail reading Not All Fruits Are Equal

How Much Sugar Is Actually in a Serving of Fruit?

“Eat more fruit. It’s good for you!” That’s what most of us grew up hearing.

But then you get bombarded on social media with the amount of sugar found in fruits, and the havoc it’s supposed to wreak on your blood sugar.

Take one medium apple. It carries around 18.9 g of sugar, which is more than half the 33.9 g in a 320-ml can of Coke.

That does sound like a lot of sugar. So should you be eating more fruit?

To answer that, let’s start with the amount of sugar in 16 commonly eaten fruits that I’ve put together.

The table lists the numbers in one serving, or around 150 g of fruit, which is a reasonable amount to eat in one sitting. That’s either one medium fruit, such as an apple or an orange, or one cup of cut or small fruit, including mango and grapes.

How Much Sugar Is in 16 Common Fruits

FruitServingSugarNo. of TeaspoonsSugar per 100 g
Grapes1 cup (151 g)23.4 g5.815.5 g
Mango1 cup (165 g)22.5 g5.613.7 g
Apple1 medium (182 g)18.9 g4.710.4 g
Tangerine2 medium (176 g)18.6 g4.710.6 g
Pear1 medium (178 g)17.4 g4.39.8 g
Banana1 large (136 g)16.6 g4.212.2 g
Pineapple1 cup (165 g)16.3 g4.19.9 g
Blueberries1 cup (148 g)14.7 g3.710.0 g
Honeydew1 cup (170 g)13.8 g3.58.1 g
Cantaloupe1 cup (160 g)12.6 g3.17.9 g
Peach1 medium (150 g)12.6 g3.18.4 g
Kiwifruit, green2 medium (138 g)12.4 g3.19.0 g
Orange1 medium (131 g)12.2 g3.19.4 g
Papaya1 cup (145 g)11.3 g2.87.8 g
Watermelon1 cup (152 g)9.4 g2.46.2 g
Strawberries1 cup (152 g)7.4 g1.94.9 g
Coke1 can (320 ml)33.9 g8.510.6 g / 100 ml

Total sugars in commonly eaten fruits from USDA FoodData Central, converted at 4 g of sugar per teaspoon.

Which Fruits Are Actually the Sweetest?

The last column is the one to read if you want to know which fruits are actually sweet, independent of how much of that fruit you’d usually eat.

Grapes top the list on both measures, while watermelon sits at the bottom on sugar per 100 g despite tasting sweet, because it’s mostly water.

The sugar in fruit is real and it isn’t trivial, so the interesting question isn’t how much sugar fruits contain, but what your body does with that sugar.

Six fruits compared by teaspoons of sugar per serving against a can of Coke
Teaspoons of sugar in one serving (about 150 g) of six common fruits, compared with a 320-ml can of Coke.

Natural vs Added Sugar: Is There Any Real Difference?

Table sugar is 100% sucrose, which our body then breaks down into equal parts of glucose and fructose.

Fruits naturally contain sucrose, as well as free glucose and fructose. However, at the end of the day when everything is digested and absorbed, most fruit sugars still end up being roughly equal parts of glucose and fructose.

There is a lot of separate research on the health effects of fructose, but we’ll leave that discussion for another time, plus no one really eats pure fructose in isolation.

So the main difference between natural vs added sugar is really about what else the sugar arrives with in your body.

Fruit sugar comes bound up in a food matrix, which is the physical structure of the whole food and everything else packaged inside it. That would include fiber, vitamins, minerals and antioxidants, all delivered at once.

Because of the food matrix, fruit sugars will generally be absorbed at a slower rate compared to sugars in a soft drink.

Not only that, it also takes at least several minutes to chew and eat a whole fruit. And that gives your gut time to send signals to your brain that you might be starting to feel full, which is something a soft drink doesn’t do.

I’ve previously discussed the metabolic impacts of added sugar, as shown by this meta-analysis of 39 randomised controlled trials.

The study found that higher sugar intake raised LDL-cholesterol by around 6.6 mg/dL (0.17 mmol/L) and triglycerides by around 11.5 mg/dL (0.13 mmol/L), even when total calories were held exactly the same.

What about fruit sugars and their effects on metabolic health?

What Happens When People Eat More Fruit?

Two trials that deliberately increased fruit intake came up with similar conclusions.

In the first study, 20 healthy Asian adults ate two gold kiwifruits with carbonated water before breakfast for 7 weeks, while the control group drank only the carbonated water.

The two gold kiwifruits would have added around 25 g of sugar per day, and the researchers confirmed the kiwifruit group really did eat more fruit sugar.

However, after 7 weeks, there was no difference between the groups in cholesterol, triglycerides, fasting glucose, insulin or uric acid. In fact, the kiwifruit group’s systolic blood pressure was even slightly lower by 2.7 mmHg.

The second trial took 63 adults with type 2 diabetes, newly diagnosed within one year, and gave everyone the same nutrition advice. They then told half the participants to eat at least two pieces of fruit a day, and the other half to eat no more than two.

At the end of 12 weeks, the higher-fruit group ended up eating 319 g, compared to 135 g of fruit in the lower-fruit group. That’s a difference of 184 g more fruit a day, which is around one medium apple.

The HbA1c in the higher-fruit group fell by 0.49%, while it also fell by 0.29% in the lower-fruit group. Even though the difference was not statistically significant, the study showed that eating one to two servings of fruit did not affect the improved metabolic outcomes.

And this is what I see in my own practice.

Clients often come to me with an elevated fasting glucose or HbA1c, and as part of my recommendations, I’ll often ask them to eat more higher-antioxidant fruits.

Almost every time, I will get initial pushback on my asking them to increase their sugar intake through fruits.

But almost every time, as long as they’re acting on the rest of my recommendations, their blood sugar numbers still improve.

Now that we’ve established that fruits are generally healthful, are there some fruits that are more beneficial than others?

Two randomised controlled trials on fruit intake showing no harm to cholesterol, glucose or insulin
Two randomised controlled trials tested fruit sugar directly. Neither found harm on any marker measured.

Which Fruits Are Linked to the Lowest Diabetes Risk?

Two large cohort studies explored this question, on opposite sides of the world.

The first study followed around 190,000 Americans for over 20 years, and found that for every additional three servings of fruit per week, the risk of developing type 2 diabetes fell by around 2%.

That might sound small. But three servings of fruit per week is only about half a serving per day, which is just half a medium apple.

That means if someone went from barely eating any fruit to eating two servings a day, they could potentially reduce their risk of type 2 diabetes by around 9%.

Digging further into the data, the fruits doing the heavy lifting were apples at 7%, grapes at 12%, and blueberries at 26% lower risk.

The second study followed around 45,000 adults right here in Singapore. Using a similar three servings a week increment, apples came in at the same 7% lower risk, and grapes at 13%.

That said, most fruits returned null results, meaning that they showed no association with either an increased or a decreased risk of type 2 diabetes. That list includes oranges, peaches, plums, papaya, honeydew and watermelon.

Even though the data and trends are surprisingly consistent, there isn’t an agreed-upon explanation for the why: sugar and fiber contents, glycaemic indices and loads all do not offer definitive trends.

My own perspective? It probably has to do with the myriad of polyphenols and phytonutrients that are abundant in fruits that we are only beginning to scratch the surface of.

Why Does Fruit Juice Blur the Line Between Natural vs Added Sugar?

Both of these studies also agreed on something else, and this is where natural sugar can suddenly become, and act as, added sugar.

In the American data, every three servings of fruit juice a week was linked to a 7% higher risk of type 2 diabetes. In the Singapore data, the risk was 11% higher.

Juicing removes the fiber, together with a large part of the antioxidant content that is found in the pulp and skin.

What’s left behind is essentially sugar (and some water-soluble vitamins like vitamin C) in a liquid form, which is not much different to a soft drink.

This randomised crossover trial got 40 participants to eat two whole apples every day for 8 weeks and, in the other arm, to consume an apple drink matched for the same sugar and the same calories for another 8 weeks.

The whole apples lowered LDL-cholesterol by around 6.6 mg/dL (0.17 mmol/L) from baseline, while the apple drink had no effect.

At the same time, while whole apples left triglycerides unchanged, the apple drink raised them by 9.7 mg/dL (0.11 mmol/L).

This is also why the World Health Organization categorises the sugar in fruit juices as free or added sugars, and not as the intrinsic, or natural sugars found in whole fruit.

Whole apples lowered LDL-cholesterol while a sugar-matched apple drink raised triglycerides
Same fruit, same sugar, same calories. Only the whole apples lowered LDL-cholesterol.

How Much Fruit Should You Eat a Day?

The short answer is less than you’d think. This large cohort study following over 100,000 adults for up to 30 years found the lowest risk of dying from any cause at just two servings of fruit a day, with no further benefit above that.

And two servings is very achievable, since each serving is either one medium fruit, or a fist-sized cup of cut fruit.

Singapore’s Health Promotion Board sets its own serving size at a slightly smaller 130 g, which is a correspondingly smaller apple or orange, one wedge of papaya, pineapple or watermelon, or one medium banana.

One caveat if you’re already diagnosed with diabetes. You will require more detailed care and advice on the consumption of fruits based on their glycaemic index and glycaemic load. So do speak to your doctor, nutritionist or dietitian about which fruits and portion sizes are appropriate for your situation.

Three Ways to Get More From the Fruit You Eat

What are some good ways to get more out of the two servings of fruit in your routine?

1. Blend your fruit if you want to drink it

Blending is not the same as juicing. A blender retains the fiber and the antioxidants, and produces more of a smoothie kind of drink.

One easy way to get your fruits in is to blend one cup of unsweetened soymilk with two of your favourite fruits.

This will not only keep the fiber and most of the nutrients from the fruits, but also adds soy protein and isoflavones from the soymilk, which are part of the soy and plant protein pillar of the cholesterol-lowering Portfolio Diet.

2. Stack your fruit with another viscous fiber

Apples, oranges and persimmons all contain pectin, a viscous fiber that lowers LDL-cholesterol in a similar way to beta-glucan in oats and barley.

So a great way to have them together would be to top your overnight oats with the cut-up fruits, which is what I do almost every morning.

3. Rotate your fruits across the week

The way I think about fruits is that they are the richest and most diverse source of polyphenols and antioxidants in our diets.

And different fruits bring different polyphenols and nutrients to the table: apples bring quercetin, blueberries are rich in anthocyanins, oranges carry vitamin C and flavanones, papaya has beta-carotene and lycopene, and bananas provide potassium.

Even though oranges, papaya and bananas were on the null list for diabetes risk above, they are still a great source of nutrients that support us in other ways.

The Bottom Line

On natural vs added sugar, the evidence indicates that natural sugars in fruits, in contrast to added sugars, are at worst not harmful, and at best, linked to better metabolic health.

Two servings of fruit a day is a good target. Eat them whole, blend them if you want to drink them, and rotate what you’re eating across the week.

Still Struggling to Move Your Cholesterol Numbers?

If you’ve been trying to lower your cholesterol and your numbers are still not moving, it might be time to look more closely at what’s working, what’s not, and why.

Book a free 15-minute strategy session with me today and get started on a personalised nutrition plan for your heart health.



Want to Learn More?

Check out these related blog posts and videos: