Is peanut butter bad for cholesterol? The answer depends not on the peanuts, but on what else might have been added to the jar.
Key Takeaways
- Peanuts and peanut butter need not affect your cholesterol the same way. Whole peanuts are generally healthy, while peanut butter’s effect on heart disease risk appears to be mixed.
- There is a wide variation in peanut butters found on the shelf. I performed an audit for six brands of peanut butter commonly sold in Singapore and found that they fall into two distinct groups.
- Some peanut butter could contain around twice the amount of saturated fat and sugar compared to other brands. Find out how to read the labels to decide which group the jar you’re eating belongs to.
- Peanut butter can be part of a cholesterol-lowering routine. Read on for a few practical tips on how to do this.

PREFER TO WATCH?
Is Peanut Butter Bad for Your Cholesterol?
Why Worry About Peanut Butter and Cholesterol?
Some of my clients have this perception that peanut butter is something that they indulge in, and is not a healthy food. And it seems to come from the idea that something so tasty cannot be healthy at the same time.
Peanut butter is a calorie-dense food that is high in fat, and that’s what gives it its decadent mouthfeel. But does that automatically make it unhealthy?
To answer that question, we need to look closer at the nutrition fact labels.
What I found across six common brands in Singapore is that the saturated fat content could range from under 5 g to over 15 g per 100 g of peanut butter. That’s potentially a three-fold difference between two jars!
At the same time, sugar content also varied just as much from below 4 g to almost 14 g.
With such wide-ranging numbers, is peanut butter healthy, and is it bad for your cholesterol?
Peanuts vs Almonds: How Does the Nutrition Compare?
Almonds are perceived by most as a healthy nut, so how would much more economical and humble peanuts measure up?
Comparing 28-g servings, or one big handful, the two nuts are very similar in terms of calories, fat, protein, and fibre.
Almonds deliver more vitamin B2 and the alpha-form of vitamin E, while peanuts bring more vitamin B3, folate, and the gamma-form of vitamin E to the table.
Both nuts also have similar amounts of copper and manganese, two minerals required for building the body’s antioxidants.
I know. Peanuts are technically legumes and not tree nuts. But because we treat them like nuts nutritionally when we eat them, I’ll continue to refer to them as “nuts” in this article.
Given the similar nutritional profile to almonds, do peanuts also have similar health benefits?
| Per 28 g, raw | Peanuts | Almonds |
|---|---|---|
| Energy | 161 kcal | 164 kcal |
| Total fat | 14.0 g | 14.2 g |
| Protein | 7.3 g (15% DV) | 6.0 g (12% DV) |
| Fiber | 2.4 g (9% DV) | 3.5 g (13% DV) |
| Vitamin B2 | 3% DV | 25% DV |
| Vitamin B3 | 21% DV | 6% DV |
| Folate | 17% DV | 3% DV |
| Vitamin E (alpha-form) | 16% DV | 48% DV |
| Vitamin E (gamma-form)a | 2.2 mg | 0.1 mg |
| Copper | 36% DV | 32% DV |
| Manganese | 24% DV | 27% DV |
Nutrient comparison between peanuts and almonds, per 28 g serving. Sources: USDA FoodData Central (all rows except gamma-tocopherol); Wyatt, Perez Carballido & Mendez (1998), J Agric Food Chem, for gamma-tocopherol.
ᵃ Gamma-tocopherol has no official %DV, since the FDA’s Vitamin E %DV reflects alpha-tocopherol only, so it’s shown in mg instead.

Is Peanut Butter Bad for Cholesterol? What the Research Actually Shows
This well-designed controlled feeding trial from 1999 found that when saturated fat in a standard diet was reduced from 16% to 7% and replaced with peanut butter, the resulting LDL-cholesterol was 13.9% lower than the standard diet. Replacing the saturated fat with peanut oil instead resulted in LDL that was also 11.1% lower.
I have discussed this in various other articles and videos, but this study reinforced the fact that not all fats are to be feared. And the substitution of foods high in saturated fat by foods high in unsaturated fats, including peanut butter, can lower LDL-cholesterol.
But does this translate to actual heart disease outcomes?
This large 2017 analysis followed over 210,000 adults for up to 32 years, and found a curious outcome.
People eating peanuts two or more times a week had a 13% lower risk of developing or dying from a heart attack or stroke, compared with those who almost never ate them.
But for peanut butter eaten at the same frequency, it had neither a positive nor a negative effect on the same outcome.
So given that peanut butter can lower LDL-cholesterol especially when substituting saturated fat, why does peanut butter not show a positive effect on actual outcomes?
Why Do Peanuts Reduce Heart Disease Risk While Peanut Butters Do Not?
The most likely explanation is that the study was unable to differentiate the different categories of peanut butter that participants were eating.
Food frequency questionnaires would ask participants how often they ate peanut butter, but wouldn’t ask which specific peanut butter they ate.
And store shelves carry two very different types of peanut butter: one that is almost pure peanuts, and another that has added ingredients.
But how different could their nutritional profiles be?
To find out, I went through the labels of 12 peanut butter products across six brands commonly sold in Singapore.
I Audited 12 Singapore Peanut Butter Products and Here’s What I Found
[Chung is not affiliated with any of the brands, products, or retailers named in this article or the accompanying video.]
I compared the nutrition labels and ingredients lists of both smooth and chunky versions of six peanut butter brands commonly sold at FairPrice and Cold Storage in Singapore.
Smooth and chunky versions of the same brand did not vary much, and the 6 brands split cleanly into two groups.
Group A consists of “all-natural” peanut butters.
They declare at least 99% peanuts used on their ingredients list, with at most salt also listed.
Per 100 g, these averaged around 6.1 g of saturated fat, 26.2 g of protein, 8.2 g of fibre, and 4.8 g of sugar.
Group B consists of formulated peanut butters.
They do not declare the percentage of peanuts used, and their ingredients lists include added sugar, vegetable oils, and in one case a stabiliser.
Per 100 g, saturated fat climbs to an average of 11.1 g, protein decreases to 21.8 g, fibre drops to 5.9 g, and sugar increases to 11.3 g.
| Group / Average Values | Saturated Fat (g) | Protein (g) | Fibre (g) | Sugar (g) | Sodium (mg) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A (all-natural, ≥99% peanuts) | 6.1 | 26.2 | 8.2 | 4.8 | 208 |
| B (formulated) | 11.1 | 21.8 | 5.9 | 11.3 | 370 |
Average composition (per 100 g) of the 12 audited peanut butter products, split into natural and formulated groups. Source: Nutrition Domus brand audit, Aug 2026.

What is also consistent is the protein and fiber moved lower together in Group B as compared to Group A. And the reason is that both nutrients must come from peanuts.
Working backwards from the protein numbers, the formulated jars in Group B probably contain somewhere around 81 to 88% peanuts. Which means that as much as one in five tablespoons in some of the jars may not be peanut at all.
And this brings us back to one possible reason why long-term inclusion of peanut butter did not show a positive outcome on heart disease risk in the study cited earlier.
If you’re wondering what’s my top choice, check it out after the tips below.
How Should You Use Peanut Butter to Support Your Cholesterol?
Peanut butter can be supportive of your LDL-cholesterol, and below are some ways I’d put it into practice.
1. Use Peanut Butter on Your Morning Toast
If you eat toast for breakfast, use peanut butter instead of butter, margarine, or kaya.
One tablespoon of butter has around 7 g of saturated fat, compared with around 0.8 to 2.4 g in a tablespoon of peanut butter. Both have similar calories, but the shift from saturated to unsaturated fat can lower LDL, as we mentioned in an earlier trial.
2. Count Peanut Butter Towards Your Portfolio Diet Points
Regular readers might remember the 25-point target from the Portfolio Diet that could lower your LDL-cholesterol by an average of 30%.
Two teaspoons of all-natural peanut butter actually counts as 1 point, so one tablespoon would give you about 1.5 points.
One great way to get even more Portfolio points is to add it to your overnight oats for a creamier texture.
3. Read the Ingredients List
Make sure that the ingredients list says only “peanuts”, with at most “salt” and nothing else.
If you see sugar, added vegetable oils, or a stabiliser, that means that you are looking at a formulated jar. That will not fit into a cholesterol-lowering Portfolio Diet as described in tip #2.
4. Use Peanut Butter in a Vegetable Dressing
In a small bowl, whisk together two tablespoons of all-natural peanut butter with the juices from half a medium orange and half a lemon, with a teaspoon of minced garlic thrown in. Add more peanut butter if the dressing turns out too watery, or more orange juice if it’s too thick.
This makes two servings, with around 1.5 Portfolio points per serving.
You can add the dressing over salad leaves, steamed kailan or bok choy, or as a dip for raw vegetables.
What Brand of Peanut Butter Is Best for High Cholesterol in Singapore?
So what’s my top pick of the lot? [Again, I’m not affiliated with any of the brands mentioned.]
Let’s first narrow it down to the three all-natural brands that could be included in a Portfolio Diet: Mother Earth, Pic’s, and Mayver’s.
Prices from Cold Storage’s online store are:
- Mother Earth: $7.75 for 380 g
- Pic’s: $8.85 for 380 g
- Mayver’s: $8.50 for 375 g
Per 100 gram of actual peanut in the jar, the three brands would rank from cheapest to most expensive:
- Mother Earth at $2.05
- Mayver’s at $2.28
- Pic’s at $2.34
100 g of Mother Earth also carries the lowest amount of saturated fat at 4.9 g, and the second lowest amount of sodium at 190 mg (Pic’s has the lowest sodium at 180 mg).
So based on health and cost factors from purely a label audit, Mother Earth wins on all counts.
That said, all three brands can be part of a cholesterol-lowering diet. And for me, I’ll always choose crunchy over smooth, but that’s a totally personal choice.

The Bottom Line
Is peanut butter bad for cholesterol? The short answer is “no”.
Peanuts are a healthy food, and all-natural peanut butter likely carries over similar nutrition and health effects.
So, get the most bang-for-your-LDL by choosing an all-natural peanut butter, and use it to replace sources of saturated fat as part of your Portfolio Diet routine.
Still Struggling to Move Your Cholesterol Numbers?
If you’ve been trying to lower your cholesterol and your numbers are still not moving, it might be time to look more closely at what’s working, what’s not, and why.
Book a free 15-minute strategy session with me today and get started on a personalised nutrition plan for your heart health.
Watch the YouTube Video
If you’d like to watch a video version of this, click below.

Want to Learn More?
Check out these related blog posts and videos:

